The Proper Treatment Of Word Order In HPSG

نویسنده

  • Karel Oliva
چکیده

This paper describes a possibility of expressing ordering constraints among non-sister constituents in binary branching syntactic structures on a local basis, supported by viewing the binary branching structure as a list (rather than a tree) of constituents within HPSGstyle grammars. The core idea of such a description of ordering is constituted by creating a type lattice for lists. The possibilities of expressing different approaches to word order in the framework are briefly discussed, exemplified and compared to other methods. In the standard immediate-constituent based approaches, the "free" word order I is described either directly in the phrase-structure (PS) rules, which thus express simultaneously both dominance (mother/daughter) relations and precedence (ordering) relations between syntactic categories, or, in more recent formalisms such as GPSG or HPSG, by the linear precedence (LP) rules creating a separate component of the grammar, whose other component is the set of immediate-dominance (ID) rules. In both these cases, the ordering constraints are limited to sister constituents, i.e. they are strictly local. One of the problems of both these variations of the standard PSapproach is the description of adjuncts (free modifiers). On the usual assumption that their number per clause is in principle not limited (though finite for a particular clause), an approach to their ordering presupposing them to be all sister constituents laust necessarily presuppose also an (at least potentially) infinite set of generative rules (e.g., a set induced by a Kleene star used in a "basic" variant of one of the rules). In languages whose grammar allows for more word order freedom than English 2, it is often the case that adjuncts and complements of a head (typically, but not solely, of a finite verb) can be freely intermixed, which makes the approach where the locality of LP constraints forces the head as well as its modifiers (both complements and adjuncts) be expanded as sisters still less attractive. Another possibility of description of word order is the "topological" approach used predominantly in more traditionally oriented German linguistics. Applied to German, this approach divides a clause into several word order "fields" ("Vorfeld", "Mittelfeld", "Nachfeld", "linke/rechte Satzklammer") whose mutual position is fixed, and studies mainly the word order regularities within these "fields". Though a lot of work has been done and many valuable insights presented within this paradigm, seen from the viewpoint of computational linguistics this approach has the fatal disadvantage that it is extremely difficult to formalize within the standard frameworks (e.g., none of the "fields" with the possible exception of "Vorfeld" creates a constituent in any usual sense etc.). AS an alternative to the two basic approaches mentioned above (as a modification of the first one, in fact), the description based on binary right-branching structures has been proposed independently in several works concerned with languages exAca~s DE COL1NG-92, NANTES, 23-28 AO~'T 1992 1 8 4 PROC. OF COLING-92, NnbrrES, AUG. 23-28, 1992 hibiting a considerable share of free word order: in (Uszkoreit,1986) for the description of verb-final clauses Jn German, in (Gunji, 1987) for Japanese and in (Avgustinova and Ol/va,1990) for (mainly) Slavic languages. However, the price paid for the removal of some problems, mainly, the free intermixing of heads, complements and adjuncts, of the abovementioned more standard descriptions is rather high at least two problematic points arise due to the strict binarity of the structure. The first of them is the fact that in binary structures no LP-rules relying on the relation "being sister constituent" can be used for ordering heads, complements and adjuncts in cases this is required, since these are not sisters any more. The second problematic point can be seen at best at the variant of the formalism given in (Avgustinova and Oliva, 1990) the occurrence of the phonologically empty rightmost element of the branching 3 (cf. the structure (1) for the string "John kissed Mary yesterday"). 6 The former problem concerning word order is in the majority of the binarybranching approaches (as far as they are at all concerned with it) solved by introducing word order mechanisms which are either of non-local nature or which burden the syntactic categories (understood as feature bundles) with otherwise unmotivated features used solely for the purpose of imposing ordering constraints (and most often, with a combination of the two). Neither approach is more fortunate than the other nonulocality is surely an unwished phenomenon in the description, and the presence of special ordering features in the categories is hardly better, i.a. also because order is a property of the syntactic structure (made of categories) rather than of the categories themselves 4 . This paper will try to show that in spite of the abovementioned reservations the "binary branching" can be a correct and fruitful approach to syntactic description if seen from a slightly different viewpoint. In order to get the proper perspective, let us observe the "binary branching" structure for the example sentence "The small boy ate an apple" shown in (2) . There are several things to be taken into consideration here. The most obvious among them is the division of the structure into "levels" contiguous sequences.of nodes with identical marking. Thus one ,,dj( .... 1,1/ \ ~f ~o NP ~ x ~ P

برای دانلود متن کامل این مقاله و بیش از 32 میلیون مقاله دیگر ابتدا ثبت نام کنید

ثبت نام

اگر عضو سایت هستید لطفا وارد حساب کاربری خود شوید

منابع مشابه

Constituency, word order and focus projection

In this study we show that constituency is of limited importance for a proper treatment of the interaction between the linear position of a wa-marked nominal in a Japanese sentence and possible domains of contrastive focus, and that constraints concerning contrastive focus should be represented in terms of linear order and not constituency. Linearisation HPSG, where linear order is independent ...

متن کامل

Information Structure and Minimal Recursion Semantics

Comparing English and Finnish, and simplifying a complex issue very much, we can say that English has fixed word order and Finnish has free word order. Syntactic theories such as HPSG (Sag and Wasow, 1999) have provided relatively successful descriptions of English, using a phrase structure approach to capture generalizations about fixed word order. Software tools such as LKB (Copestake, 2000) ...

متن کامل

A classification of hull operators in archimedean lattice-ordered groups with unit

The category, or class of algebras, in the title is denoted by $bf W$. A hull operator (ho) in $bf W$ is a reflection in the category consisting of $bf W$ objects with only essential embeddings as morphisms. The proper class of all of these is $bf hoW$. The bounded monocoreflection in $bf W$ is denoted $B$. We classify the ho's by their interaction with $B$ as follows. A ``word'' is a function ...

متن کامل

Iranian Advanced EFL Learners’ Awareness and the Use of Marked Word Order: Discourse-pragmatically Motivated Variations

The present investigation was designed to study the production and comprehension of specific means for information highlighted by advanced Iranian learners of English as a Foreign Language. The study focused on the discourse-pragmatically motivated variations of the basic word order such as inversion, pre-posing, it- and Wh-clefts. After taking the Nelson test, a homogeneous group was settled. ...

متن کامل

Scrambling in German : Extraction into the Mittelfeld

German is a language with a relatively free word order. During the last few years considerable efforts have been made in all syntactic frameworks to explain so-called scrambling phenomena. In the following paper, I deal with some tough cases of German word order which cannot be described by assuming flat sentence structures or word order domains. The phenomena discussed are PP complements of no...

متن کامل

Figure heads in HPSG

Figure heads are words without autonomous content, such as the copula and the infinitival to. They pose a challenge for the head-driven semantics of HPSG-94, since the latter requires the CONTENTjNUCLEUS value of a head-complement combination to be identical to the one of its head daughter. As a consequence, if the head is semantically vacuous, the combination is —erroneously— predicted to be v...

متن کامل

ذخیره در منابع من


  با ذخیره ی این منبع در منابع من، دسترسی به آن را برای استفاده های بعدی آسان تر کنید

برای دانلود متن کامل این مقاله و بیش از 32 میلیون مقاله دیگر ابتدا ثبت نام کنید

ثبت نام

اگر عضو سایت هستید لطفا وارد حساب کاربری خود شوید

عنوان ژورنال:

دوره   شماره 

صفحات  -

تاریخ انتشار 1992